The Urban Sketch Writer

Blog

  • Car dependency, GDP and inclusive design

    Car dependency, GDP and inclusive design

    [This content first appeared on LinkedIn on 6 November 2024]

    Yowza! How apropos a question raised in my previous post seems to have been! Namely: Why are we still approving development with substandard access to public transport?

    Well, lo and behold, Peter Walker of the Guardian, no less, has attempted to answer that question by publishing an article on how “Planning rules have failed to link new homes to public transport.”

    It turns out that a study by the RTPI has found that the last ten years of constant chatter about building in sustainable locations with good transport infrastructure has literally fallen on deaf ears.

    There are a number of repercussions to this that anyone who’s been placemaking for over half an hour and has a duty of care to the public will understand:

    • People have to become car dependent out of necessity 
    • This has implications for people’s health…
    • … as well as their finances
    • It disadvantages those on low incomes
    • It disadvantages those who for whatever reason cannot drive, or do not want to drive
    • It makes access to shops, schools, colleges, workplaces, doctors’ surgeries etc. etc. etc. an arduous task in what is apparently a civilised society with sufficient GDP to send us straight in at No6 in the Top Ten countdown of global economies

    Not a good look.

    This week my Urban Design 101 request is a return to strategic level design, reviewing the morphology of existing settlements well served by public transport to investigate how these could be sustainably expanded to accommodate housing need.

    It’s quite clear that the current system of the ‘call for sites’, where land comes forward in an often delightfully ad-hoc manner, often in fields with questionable topography and drainage issues, often far from anywhere and which would just result in yet more car dependency… *checks notes*… isn’t working. 

    I’m not the only one to reach this conclusion – take a look at ‘Achieving Good Town Form’, the latest Urban Design Group paper.

    If we are going to design inclusively – which includes providing the community with a viable choice of travel options – we have to get the public transport links right. 

    A few miles up the road a still-under-construction major, major housing development has had to abandon a bus route through the site because the streets in the neighbouring development parcel weren’t wide enough to accommodate it. But all is not lost! Residents can still walk a quarter of a mile alongside a dual-carriageway on a path that isn’t overlooked to a stop that is barely overlooked by a single house to catch a bus into town.

    And on the way home again, they have the pleasure of crossing that dual-carriageway via staggered crossings. 

    Not much of a selling point even while the fare is still capped at £2.

    Phones and keys at the ready, ladies! 

    Amirite?

    #peterwalker #guardian #amirite #placemaking #placemakers #urbandesign #publictransport #bus

  • Soairse Ronan, Marina Hyde and Jane Jacobs walk onto the Graham Norton Show…

    [This content first appeared on LinkedIn on 30 October 2024]

    Unless you’ve been living under a rock since Friday 25 October 2024, you’ve no doubt seen the clip of Saoirse Ronan on The Graham Norton Show telling the lads to basically STFU when it comes to talking about women’s safety, a topic they clearly know nothing about.

    Happily, they actually took notice and did.

    As Marina Hyde points out in her Guardian article: “… what they can’t do, even with all their combined decades of Acting, is think their way into the part of literally any woman, in any place, walking home after dark or on an almost deserted route on just another day of a lifetime of knowing she could be prey. You get quite good at thinking about how boring little things like phones or keys could defend you in those moments, as any woman will wearily concede. We all dream of a future without this forever hum of fear, where we too could join in the absurdist joke.”

    But my question to you is, what are we doing, as placemakers, to deliver a public realm where everyone – not just women and girls – feel safe to be there at any time regardless of gender, age, disability, race or religious belief?

    • Why are we still approving development where routes are not well overlooked or lit?
    • Why are we still approving development riddled with areas of concealment?
    • Why are we still approving development that is car-orientated and discriminatory to those walking and wheeling?
    • Why are we still approving development with substandard access to public transport?
    • Why are we still approving development where most of the pavements end up blocked by parked cars?

    And why are we in a situation where, according to Public Practice, 43% of respondents to their Recruitment and Skills Report say they lack the funding to recruit the required placemaking staff?

    It’s all well and good the government setting a housing target of 1.5million homes over the next parliament, but how are we going to ensure these are built to the highest design standards when there are huge resource gaps in over-stretched planning departments?

    In response can I at the very least demand a return to the basics – Urban Design 101 – and lobby for a return to street-based urbanism, à la Jane Jacobs, creating places with gentle density to accommodate a critical mass of population… short blocks to create a variety of routes between destinations… mixed use development to bring people out on the street at different times… street trees and hard and soft landscape that enhance the quality of the place… good enclosure of streets by buildings to enable eyes on the street… a ban on pavement parking.

    We need to stop designing to accommodate the refuse vehicles first and foremost and finally start prioritising the people who will actually live, work and roller-skate there. We have more than enough guidance and policy to show us how to do these things.

    As Saoirse would say: “Amirite ladies?”

    #saoirseronan #marinahyde #guardian #amirite #placemaking #placemakers #publicpractice #janejacobs #eyesonthestreet #urbandesign